Things I Liked:
I actually had heard good things about this book, but thought I probably wouldn't like it much. But, a welcome surprise, I loved it! It was a really suspenseful and exciting story. I found myself very invested in the characters, especially Nick, though he displays the least emotions. The interactions between Alan and Nick were interesting and real - how I imagine a lot of brothers interact. I also loved the sarcastic humor, probably because my family uses sarcastic humor. I actually figured out a huge plot twist before it was revealed, but that didn't detract from my enjoyment at all. I especially loved the choices Nick had to make near the end of the book and how he had to think about himself deeply. A thoughtful and well written story.
Things I Didn't Like:
I really hate the cover - the guy looks too cheesy for me. I think I might be in the minority on that though. I actually got hung up on the third person narrator a few times. I thought it might have been better told from Nick's perspective. But, it didn't bother me much during the action. I also noticed a minor flaw in the story that didn't get picked up on by the editors. Again, though, I really didn't care.
Read-alikes:
It was a bit like the The Abhorsen Chroniclesby Garth Nix
I was also reminded of The Bartimaeus Trilogyby Jonathan Stroud
BOOK CONTENT RATINGS:
s-factor: !@
a couple scattered throughout
mrg-factor: X
some suggestion, but nothing described
v-factor: ->->
there is some slashing and killing
Overall rating: ****
What is one of your "pleasantly surprised" reads?
I've really been looking forward to this one. And I agree on the cover. I like the UK one much better. But your comments on the sarcastic humor and the brother interaction really have me excited. Thanks for the review!
ReplyDeleteAngiegirl, I hope you like it! I better go check out the UK cover.
ReplyDeleteMy teenager refused to read it, because the guy looks like he has lipstick on. I may have to check it out again.
ReplyDeleteI like the read-alikes, so I'd probably like this one too. You're right--the cover is horrid. I never would have picked it up off the shelf.
ReplyDeleteSharon, yeah, I felt like I had to hide the cover from people. It is unfortunate.
ReplyDeleteCara, I wouldn't have picked it up without all the great reviews I've seen. I'd say it's worth the embarrassment to get it :)
Cover didn't bother me, but I LOVED this. A great one for students who demand horror and suspense. There is a sequel in the offing as well.
ReplyDelete